Wallpaper Games: Animepaper.net Archives

WG Archives

Match 09: Battle of the Bands

————————

Match 09: Battle of the Bands!

————————

Final Judging Total’s

Mirtillo> 51.5 >WINNER [1st]

Nailu> 49.5 [4th]

The Major> 51.0 >Runner Up [2nd]

AngelEarth10> 49.0 [5th]

SailorDove> 50.0 [3rd]

————————————-

match09 first place gold 01

[AP.net Badge = ‘Paper Prize’ 250 papers]

[full view at imagevenue.com] “Rousing Sound” created by: Mirtillo

————————————-

match09 possible 2rd place silver 01

[AP.net Badge = ‘Paper Prize’ 100 papers]

“Rock Out Loud” created by: TheMajor

match09 possible 3rd place bronze 01

[AP.net Badge = ‘Paper Prize’ 50 papers]

Ami's Music - Widescreen

[full view in Minitokyo.net] “Ami’s Music” created by: SailorDove

————————————-

a_013

[AP.net Badge = ‘Paper Prize’ 25 papers]

Dream Usagi000-Clean Version 0003

[full view in Minitokyo.net] “Usagi: Punk Rocker” created by: AngelEarth10

a_042

[AP.net Badge = ‘Paper Prize’ 25 papers]

“Underneath Your Skin” created by: Nailu

———————————————————–

Judges Scores and Comments

——————————

Judge: Ziraki

Entry#1: Mirtillo: “Rousing Sound” A#1: 4 A#2: 5 A#3: 4.5 = 13.5

Entry#2: Nailu: “Underneath Your Skin” A#1: 5 A#2: 4 A#3: 4 = 13

Entry#3: TheMajor: “Rock Out Loud” A#1: 5 A#2: 4 A#3: 5 = 14

Entry#4: angelearth10: “Usagi; Punk Rocker” A#1: 4.5 A#2: 5 A#3: 4.5 =14

Entry#5: SailorDove: “Ami’s Music” A#1: 4.5 A#2: 4 A#3: 4 = 13

——————————
Judge: SamB

Mirtillo: “Rousing Sound” : total score = 11.0

Does the wallpaper contain anything musical? 4.5

Using a piano and music papers it was a really good choice because show clearly and with evidentness the theme.

_Is the wallpaper well contructed? Visually and Technically. _ 3.5

Technically the wallpaper is good done especially because is clean. The graphic construction is nice but the colors are a little off and the background is flat without any effects.

Do you like the overall wall on its own merit? 3.0

In this wallpaper I like very much the concept and the general idea. The character is good putted into it but its face his a little weird and don’t attractive me really much.

Nailu: “Underneath Your Skin” : total score = 7.5

Does the wallpaper contain anything musical? 2.5

It’s clear that the character is listening music but only an Ipod and two “music note” are too feeble elements respect the contest theme.

_Is the wallpaper well contructed? Visually and Technically. _ 2.5

The character is well done and light effects are good but unfortunatly there are some problems. First the Ipod style is too much different respect other elements, the music notes are putted casually without sense and the text ruin a little the composition and more important it’s a mistake the choice of its color because over the character’s shirt is not readable.

Do you like the overall wall on its own merit? 2.5

The graphic construction is interesting and the light and lines effects are attractive but, unfortunatly, there are some mistake that I dislike.

TheMajor: “Rock Out Loud” : total score = 6.5

Does the wallpaper contain anything musical? 3.0

The character that play a guitar helps to recognize the theme but I think it was better to put more music elements.

_Is the wallpaper well contructed? Visually and Technically. _ 1.5

The character is well centred but there is too contrast between the vivid colors of the character and the dark bakcground. The effects in the background are too many and putted casually without coherence.

Do you like the overall wall on its own merit? 2.0

I don’t like this wallpaper because in my opinion is too chaotic and it isn’t elegant.

angelearth10: “Usagi; Punk Rocker” : total score = 7.5

Does the wallpaper contain anything musical? 2.0

Music elements are too feeble. I could see only a music stereo line behind the character but it’s not sufficient for me.

_Is the wallpaper well contructed? Visually and Technically. _ 3.0

The character is well centred and some elements in the background are really well done and interesting, but other elements aren’t putted well and they are too much that don’t make the background very elegant.

Do you like the overall wall on its own merit? 2.5

I dislike a lot of background elements, I think a more simple result could be more acctractive especially the hearts are not coherent with the others elements.

SailorDove: “Ami’s Music” : total score = 10.5

Does the wallpaper contain anything musical? 3.5

The music theme is clear but not very original.

_Is the wallpaper well contructed? Visually and Technically. _ 3.5

Technically is simple but the graphic construction is really coherent and putted well. The graphic effects are actractive and generally they made better the final graphic impact. Unfortunatly the concept isn’t very original.

Do you like the overall wall on its own merit? 3.5

In this one I really like its graphic choices especially to use the character silhouette that make particular the wallpaper but it’s a little boring and flat (especially for the monochrome choice).

——————————
Judge: Blulaguna18

Wallpaper [1] : 2.5

Wallpaper [2] : 3

Wallpaper [3] : 4.5

Wallpaper [4] : 2.5

Wallpaper [5] : 3.5
——————————

Judge: Whisper2dawind

Mirtillo – adherence to theme = 5 – visually = 4.5 – technically = 4 – overall = 4.5 > 14.5

Nailu – adherence to theme = 5 – visually = 3 – technically = 3.5 – overall = 3 > 13

The Major – adherence to theme = 5 – visually = 4 – technically = 4 – overall = 4 > 14

Angelearth10 – adherence to theme = 5 – visually = 3.5 – technically = 3.5 – overall = 4 > 14

SailorDove – adherence to theme = 5 – visually = 3 – technically = 3.5 – overall = 3 > 13

——————————
Judge:Eldarwen

1) 5, 2,3 = 10

2) 5, 4, 4 =13

3) 4, 4, 4 =12

4) 3, 4, 4 =11

5) 5,2,3 =10

———————————————————–

 Wallpaper Games group Official Blog @Wordpress

 Wallpaper Games group @Minitokyo

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: