Match 06: Father like Son/Mother like Daughter

————————

Match 06: Father Like Son/Mother Like Daughter

————————

Final Judging Total’s

Darkangelvelvet> 41.5

Mirtillo> 51.0

Runner Up>  FlameColonelRoy> 47.5

AngelEarth10> 56.5 > Winner

———***——————***——————***———

[AP.net Badge = ‘Paper Prize’ N/A] [full view in DeviantArt!] “From: Usagi and Chibi-Usa” created by: AngelEarth10

———***——————***——————***———

[AP.net Badge = ‘Paper Prize’ N/A] [full view at imagevenue.com] “Tiger Girls” created by: Mirtillo

[AP.net Badge = ‘Paper Prize’ N/A] [full @ photobucket.com] “Saiyan And Son” created by: FlameColonelRoy

———***——————***——————***———

[AP.net Badge = ‘Paper Prize’ N/A] [full view in Minitokyo.net] “Snowy Day” created by: Kuryuki

[AP.net Badge = ‘Paper Prize’ N/A] “Mommy and Me” created by: TheMajor

———***——————***——————***———

[AP.net Badge = ‘Paper Prize’ N/A] [full view in Minitokyo.net]  “The Wall of Memories”  created by: DarkAngelVelvet aka HydeExile @MiniTokyo.net

———————————————————–

MATCH 6: Judging Results and comments

————-

Judge: Ziraki

Entry#1 Darkangelvelvet: Wall of Memories A#1: 5 A#2: 3.5 2#3: 5 = 13.5

Entry#4 Mirtillo: Tiger Girls A#1: 4 A#2: 3 A#3: 3 = 10

Entry#5: FlameColonelRoy: Saiyan and Son A#1: 4 A#2: 3 A#3: 3.5 = 10.5

Entry#6: angelearth10: From Usagi and Chibi-Usa A#1: 4.5 A#2: 4 A#3: 4 = 12.5

=====================

Judge: SamB

Darkangelvelvet: Wall of Memories : total score = 4.0

Does the wallpaper contain a Father and Son OR a Mother and Daughter WITH any similarity = 1.0

In this wallpaper I can’t see any parenthood connection between the characters. This is an out-theme for me.

Is the wallpaper well constructed? Visually and Technically. = 1.5

The characters are good with their vivid colors and they are centered int the wallpaper and that is good, too. Contrary the background has a lot of problems. Some images appeares streched and the frames have too strong effects and they disappeare in a transparence that show themselves unrealistic. Technically isn’t a good graphic work.

Do you like the overall wall on its own merit? = 1.5

Unfortunatly I don’t like this wallpaper for the reason that I wrote. It’ s chaotic and confuse.

Mirtillo: Tiger Girls : total score = 13.0

Does the wallpaper contain a Father and Son OR a Mother and Daughter WITH any similarity = 5.0

The parenthood between the characters are really evident with the same hair color and the same tiger dresses too. This is a very good choice.

Is the wallpaper well constructed? Visually and Technically. = 4.0

Technically the wallpaper is simple but very well done. The choice of colors is great and the graphic composition is really eye-catching, clear and clean.

Do you like the overall wall on its own merit? = 4.0

In this wallpaper I like especially the circle cascade and the choice of their colors that contrast very well respect the green of the background. It’a a very good work in my opinion.

FlameColonelRoy: Saiyan and Son : total score = 7.5

Does the wallpaper contain a Father and Son OR a Mother and Daughter WITH any similarity = 5.0

The parenthood is evident and the popularity of the anime helps to recognize the characters immediately.

Is the wallpaper well constructed? Visually and Technically. = 1.0

Technically the wallpaper is feeble and the graphic construction is poor. The background hasn’t a sense respect the characters and they aren’t putted in any kind of relation each other but the characters seem to be putted on the wallpaper casually.

Do you like the overall wall on its own merit? = 1.5

Unfortunatly the poorness of the construction and the background so flat aren’t actrective for me.

angelearth10: From Usagi and Chibi-Usa : total score = 11.0

Does the wallpaper contain a Father and Son OR a Mother and Daughter WITH any similarity = 5.0

The parenthood is evident and clear, more that the popularity of the anime helps to recognize the character relationship immediately.

Is the wallpaper well constructed? Visually and Technically. = 3.0

Technically the wallpaper is simple, without eyes-catching effects, but the graphic construction is nice and clean. Characters are well centered and the characters connection is really nice, too. The background has good colors.

Do you like the overall wall on its own merit? = 3.0

In this wallpaper I like especially some choice made as the scan and the colors used, but the background isn’t attrective for me.

————————————

Judge: Bluelaguna18

[1] : 1 ‘

[4] : 4

[5] : 3.5

[6] : 5

————————————

Judge: Whisper2dawind

Darkangelvelvet – adherence to theme = 5 – visually = 3 – technically = 3 – overall = 3 > T=13

Mirtillo – adherence to theme = 5 – visually = 3.5 – technically = 3.5 – overall = 4 > T=14

FlameColonelRoy – adherence to theme = 5 – visually = 3 – technically = 3 – overall = 3 > T=13

Angelearth10 – adherence to theme = 5 – visually = 3 – technically = 4 – overall = 4 > T=14

————————————

Judge: Eldarwen

1) 2, 4, 4 = 10

4) 4, 3, 3 = 10

5) 5, 2, 4 = 13

6) 5, 4, 5 =14

———————————————————–

 Wallpaper Games group Official Blog @Wordpress

 Wallpaper Games group @Minitokyo